Although most legal academics greatly exaggerate the extent to which controversial legal questions can be reduced to technical exercises in formal rule application, most such people, especially at elite institutions, also recognize that technical competence by itself cannot determine the outcome of Supreme Court cases.
However, she also stirred up controversy when she banned military recruiters from the campus due to its refusal to let openly gay people serve in the military and criticized the policy strongly. At the entry level, candidates are by Nomination of elena kagan essay evaluated largely on the basis of their potential: If your post does not follow our policy, it will be deleted.
I think both of them are correct, I think it will be an indicator of how strong President Obama deals, and what shape the Democratic party is in when the pick is made.
Kagan continued blocking equal access by military recruiters even after the Third Circuit stayed its own decision.
A supposed positive of nominating Kagan is that she does not have a paper record. And I think having someone, assuming he does testify, like Charles Fried before the Senate Judiciary Committee, does provide her a great deal of cover with conservatives. Facebook 0 Twitter 0 livefyre Email Print Last month, Chief Justice Roberts gave his annual year-end report on the federal judiciary, but it was quite different from prior ones.
But that does not account for the vast difference in their publication records. Some are critical legal study scholars. So, all things being equal, it should have been much more difficult for Kagan to get a lateral offer at Harvard in than it had been to get an entry-level job at Chicago eight years earlier.
This is what G. Merrick Garland was acceptable to Orrin Hatch and to a number of Republicans. Now, the combination of native ability, hard work, driving ambition, personal connections, and general social privilege people such as Kagan can draw upon in such situations paid spectacular dividends.
I think picking Elena Kagan for the Supreme Court, with all due respect to Elena Kagan, is sort of like ordering chicken in a fancy restaurant. From what I understand, [Merrick Garland] was the runner-up for the Kagan position.
Attorney who becomes a judge. Having read at least three pieces, they are good.
I think people are going to be interested in hearing her views on executive power, and the war on terror. Inveteran U. Later that year, U. She joined the court and made a positive impression on her colleagues with her friendly personality and was expected to join the liberal faction of the Court, just as Stevens and Souter had.
National Right to Life works through legislation and education to protect those threatened by abortion, infanticide, euthanasia and assisted suicide. Law faculties tend to be fractious places, and plenty of people at Harvard, not all of whom she hired, believe she did an excellent job.
On the basis of those conversations, as well as the public record, the following story emerges. We value our readers and encourage their participation, but in order to ensure a positive experience for our readership, we have a few guidelines for commenting on articles. If you wish to comment on another subject, you may search for a relevant article and join or start a discussion there.
These calls have intensified with the release of recent emails. First, her phraseology was much more precise. Circuit inmay not be sitting on the Supreme Court today. It seems she soon regretted that decision.Elena Kagan's Supreme Court nomination is becoming contentious because of tensions over sensitive documents related to her career.
The right was able to torpedo the nomination of Harriet Miers, because she was unacceptable to them, and it would be a better world if the left could/would do so to Elena Kagan.
Or more accurately, if Obama knew that the left would do. killarney10mile.com PN — Elena Kagan, of Massachusetts, to be an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, vice John Paul Stevens, retiring.
Aug. 5, Confirmed by the Senate by Yea-Nay Vote. 63 - After weeks of speculation, it was leaked yesterday that Elena Kagan would be President Obama’s U.S.
Supreme Court nominee. It’s doubtful many were surprised by the news, but lawyers have a. IN THE day since her nomination, we've heard a flood of compliments about Elena Kagan from everyone who's ever worked with her, which includes much of the Democratic aristocracy.
Barack Obama. Elena Kagan's responses to the questions put to her by the Senate are worthy of comment since she has been nominated for a significant position. A companion piece to this article will review some.Download